Feeling Lost in the AI Recruitment Maze? - Why Your Tools Aren't Working (and How to Get Real Results)

Australian recruitment agencies: Are your AI tools or the AI assistants inside your software tools underperforming? Learn why generic prompts fail, how to master prompt engineering, and why a strategic, human-centric approach is key to AI success.

The promise of AI in recruitment is undeniably alluring. Automate tasks, find better quality candidates faster, and gain a competitive edge – it sounds fantastic. Many Australian recruitment agencies have enthusiastically embraced these new technologies, signing up for various platforms and expecting immediate improvements.

But for many, the reality hasn't quite lived up to the hype. The tools are there, the subscriptions are active, but the results are… underwhelming.

Why?

The simple answer is that AI isn't magic. It's not a set-it-and-forget-it solution. It requires understanding, strategy, scope, and, most importantly, skillful direction.

Beyond the Sign-Up Button: Why AI Isn't a Mind Reader (and Why That Matters)

A common misconception is that AI can intuitively understand your needs. You sign up, type in a basic request like "find me a software developer," and expect the AI to magically deliver a shortlist of perfect candidates. This is where the "garbage in, garbage out" principle comes into play. AI is incredibly powerful at processing information and identifying patterns, but it relies entirely on the information you provide it. More specifically, unless you train it, it has no idea of what “good” looks like it will just return an answer or reply unless it understands outcomes and what success looks like.

Think of your AI tool as a highly skilled, but utterly literal, research assistant. If you give vague instructions, you'll get vague results. It doesn't know your company culture, your specific hiring criteria, what success looks like for your business or the unspoken qualities that make a candidate truly exceptional. It needs explicit guidance.

The "Write a job ad" example from earlier is a perfect illustration. A generic request yields a generic response. But a detailed, specific prompt – outlining the role, the company, the target audience, and the desired tone – transforms the AI from a blunt instrument into a precision tool. Once you have this mastered you can take your AI precision tool to the next level and train it on which job adverts are the most successful using your previous shortlist, interview and placement data.

The High Cost of Low-Effort AI: Wasted Subscriptions and Missed Opportunities

• Bad Prompt: "Find me a marketing manager."
  
  
• Pitfalls: This is incredibly broad. The AI has no idea what kind of marketing manager you need. It will likely return a wide range of candidates, many of whom will be completely unsuitable. This wastes your time, forcing you to manually sift through irrelevant profiles. It also misses out on potentially perfect candidates who might not be actively using the generic term "marketing manager" in their profiles if their experience is highly specialised. You get quantity, not quality.
• Benefits of Specificity (Good Prompt): "Find me a marketing manager with experience in the FMCG sector in Melbourne, with a strong track record in digital marketing and team leadership. Must have at least 5 years of experience."
• Benefits: This prompt provides the AI with crucial filters:
• Industry: FMCG (Fast-Moving Consumer Goods) narrows the field considerably.
• Location: Melbourne specifies the geographic area.
• Skills: Digital marketing and team leadership define the core competencies.
• Experience: "At least 5 years" sets a minimum seniority level.
• This level of detail drastically increases the likelihood of finding relevant candidates quickly. It saves time, reduces irrelevant results, and improves the overall efficiency of your search. The AI can leverage keywords and semantic understanding to find candidates who match your exact needs, even if they don't perfectly match every word in your prompt.
• Take it up a level:  If and when you have mastered the above then your level up is using a great candidate you already have in the system, maybe one you already placed. If you have trained your AI well and your have enriched your database with good quality data then your level up would just be”find me more candidates like this one” and the AI will do all the heavy lifting for you.

Tone Matters:

• Bad Prompt: "Write a job ad for a sales executive."
  
  
• Pitfalls: This prompt lacks any indication of the desired tone or style. The AI will likely default to a generic, corporate tone, which might not be appropriate for the company or the role. A bland job ad fails to attract attention, doesn't convey the company culture, and won't resonate with the target audience. It may even actively deter the best candidates, who are looking for something more than just a generic description.
• Benefits of Tone (Good Prompt): "Write an enthusiastic and persuasive job ad for a Business Development Manager role at a fast-growing SaaS company in Sydney. Target driven, ambitious individuals with experience in B2B sales."
• Benefits: This prompt sets the tone explicitly:
• Enthusiastic and persuasive: This tells the AI to use energetic and compelling language.
• Fast-growing SaaS company: This gives context about the company culture and the type of work environment.
• Target driven, ambitious individuals: This describes the personality traits you're seeking.
• B2B sales: specifies the type of sales experience required.
• By specifying the tone, you ensure the job ad aligns with your brand, attracts the right candidates, and effectively sells the opportunity. It helps create a consistent brand voice and makes the ad more engaging.
• Take it up a level:  If and when you have mastered the above then your level up is to use a combination of the power of the rich data in your system and the AI tool. Your prompt would be "Write an enthusiastic and persuasive job ad for a Business Development Manager role at a fast-growing SaaS company in Sydney. Target driven, ambitious individuals with experience in B2B sales also using similar job adverts where a placement has been made or a large number of candidates made it to the status of shortlist or interview.

Context is Crucial:

• Bad Prompt: "Summarise this candidate's resume."
  
  
• Pitfalls: While seemingly straightforward, this is inefficient. The AI will provide a general summary, including potentially irrelevant information. You'll still have to read through the summary to find the key details relevant to the specific role you're hiring for. This defeats the purpose of using AI for summarisation.
• Benefits of Context (Good Prompt): "Summarise this candidate's resume, highlighting their experience relevant to a Project Manager role in the construction industry. Focus on their experience with large-scale projects and stakeholder management."
• Benefits: This prompt provides critical context:
• Target Role: Project Manager in the construction industry.
• Key Skills: Large-scale projects and stakeholder management.
• This directs the AI to extract only the information relevant to the specific role. It saves you significant time by pre-filtering the resume content and presenting the most important details upfront. You get a targeted summary, not a generic one.
• Take it up a level:  If and when you have mastered the above then your level up is to use templates and attachments to give your AI tool more context and structure. For example you would attach to your good prompt your company's formatted CV template and an example of a completed good candidate summary that you have already sent to a client. 

Iterate, Iterate, Iterate:

• Initial Prompt: "Write a LinkedIn post about the benefits of flexible work arrangements."
• Pitfall: Good starting point but not great, no company branding and no call to action.
• Evaluation: The post is too generic and doesn't mention our agency.
• Refined Prompt: "Write a LinkedIn post about the benefits of flexible work arrangements for attracting top talent in the tech industry. Mention [Your Agency Name]'s expertise in placing candidates in flexible roles. Include a call to action to visit our website."
• Benefit: Provides branding and directs traffic to a landing page.
• Benefits of Iteration: The iterative process is essential because AI output is rarely perfect on the first try.
• Feedback Loop: By evaluating the initial output and refining the prompt, you create a feedback loop that progressively improves the results.
• Learning: You learn how the AI responds to different types of instructions, becoming a more effective prompt engineer over time.
• Optimisation: Iteration allows you to fine-tune the output to perfectly match your requirements, ensuring the final product is exactly what you need.
• Take it up a level:  If and when you have mastered the above then your level up is to start with your optimised iteration on the new prompt for a LinkedIn Post. Based on the AI tool or software you are using it should be learning from your last iteration and not starting each time with no understanding of what good is.

Define the Role and Desired output

• Bad Prompt: "Help me find candidates"
  
  
• Pitfalls: Far to vauge, there is no parameters for the AI to search against.
  
  
• Benefits of defining (Good Prompt): "Generate 20 unique and probing interview questions for a Senior Accountant position at a non-profit organisation in Brisbane. Focus on questions that assess their financial analysis skills, experience with grant management, and commitment to ethical financial practices. Tailor the questions to someone with more than 5 years experience"
• Benefits: Provides a framework that is easy to follow and also creates specific areas to focus on to gather more specific targeted information.
• Clear output defined: The prompt has asked for a very specific amount and output.
• Job role and location: The parameters are set.
• Key areas to focus on: The prompt is dialled into very niche skills and experience.
• Experience defined: This allows the AI to be even more specific with the response, creating questions that are more suited for the right level of experience.
• Take it up a level:  If and when you have mastered the above then your level up is to add on interview questions from similar successful placements and guidelines such as your companies best practice guide on how to interview candidates.

In essence, these examples demonstrate that the quality of the AI's output is directly proportional to the quality of the input. Clear, specific, and well-contextualised prompts lead to relevant, useful results, while vague or poorly defined prompts lead to wasted time and effort. The more you put into the prompt, the more you get out of the AI.

However, this is only just the beginning, milestone one of your AI journey. You need to continually go past the initial outputs and teach your AI what good looks like. The higher quality the data it is provided and the context of what a successful outcome is, the better your results will be.



Beyond Automation: Building a Human-AI Partnership

It's crucial to remember that AI is a tool to enhance, not replace, human expertise. The best recruitment strategies combine the efficiency of AI with the insight, empathy, and relationship-building skills of experienced recruiters.

AI can handle the initial sifting and sorting, identifying potentially qualified candidates based on keywords and criteria. It can automate repetitive tasks, freeing up recruiters to focus on:

• Building rapport with candidates: Understanding their career aspirations, motivations, and cultural fit.
• Engaging with clients: deeply understanding their needs and building long-term partnerships.
• Making informed decisions: Using their judgement and experience to assess candidates beyond the resume.

Taking Control of Your AI Journey: From Frustration to Results

The key takeaway is this: Don't be a passive consumer of AI. Be an active, informed user. Invest the time to learn the principles of prompt engineering, experiment with different approaches, and develop a strategy that aligns with your agency's specific goals. Start with one tool, master it, and then consider expanding your AI arsenal. 



This is the first time in history that you will need to have a continual change and learning approach to  your recruitment and AI tools to stay ahead. You are recruitment business owners, not product or change managers, reach out for help, collaborate with others and find great external resources to follow to keep you up to date with this changing landscape. If in doubt or you are struggling, find yourself some great internal AI ambassadors or external specialists to help you on this journey.

Want a free 15 coaching session on your use of AI tools in your recruitment agancy? - Fill in the form below